On Goalie Interference

I ranted on Twitter a bit during the Red Wings’ eventually-unsuccessful challenge of the Penguins’ first goal of the game.

It may seem a little disingenuous to compare modern goalie interference calls to those levied against a player who retired three years ago. Rules have changed since then. Video review of Holmstrom’s goalie interference calls was never an option.

The reason I do it, though, is because – while we now have video review – the actual definition of goalie interference has not changed. Which means that, in theory, plays now should be held to the same standard that Holmstrom was during his career.

We saw Detroit goals disallowed because Holmstrom was hovering over the crease, not making contact with the goaltender. Plays where the refs went to center ice and announced that a goal was coming back because a player was in the crease. We saw that multiple times a season and no one in the league offices or the media even blinked, despite that not being the rule.

Tonight we saw a skater planted in the crease, seemingly pushing the goalie around in it, and we debate whether that contact really made a difference. No one suggests that his mere presence in the blue paint should negate the goal. Even with video review to get the call right, the call that was made against Holmstrom never gets made now.

So I rant because it’s an implicit admission that all those calls throughout his career were wrong. If the standards are the same, and video review allows us to get it right, and someone standing in the crease and pushing the goalie around is a legal play, then Tomas Holmstrom‘s entire reputation for committing goalie interference was fabricated. I want to force people to see – and maybe acknowledge – that.

Pregame: Penguins @ Red Wings – 12/31

It’s Detroit’s traditional New Year’s Eve home game tonight as the Red Wings host the Pittsburgh Penguins.

Jonathan Ericsson returns to the Detroit lineup, with Jakub Kindl the odd-man out on the blue line. Joakim Andersson will sit in favor of Tomas Nosek on the fourth line.

Petr Mrazek gets the start in goal for the Wings.

Stupid stat of the day: The Red Wings are unbeaten all-time against Pittsburgh on New Year’s Eve in games where the Penguins wear black and gold. Detroit’s lone NYE loss to the Pens came in 1978 when they still wore blue and white.

Game time is 6:00 PM on FSD.

DetroitHockey.Net is not officially affiliated with the Detroit Red Wings organization or the National Hockey League

Sort By Date (Oldest to Newest)